Sheet Metal Roofing vs. Traditional Roofing: Which is Right for Your Property?

Back To News

Sheet metal roofing vs. traditional roofing is one of the toughest choices property owners face. The material you choose impacts everything: upfront cost, long-term durability, energy savings, and even curb appeal. 

You want a roof that fits your budget today but also protects your investment tomorrow. That’s why comparing modern sheet metal roofing with traditional options is the smartest way to determine which provides the best value, performance, and peace of mind.

Sheet Metal Roofing: A Versatile and Modern Roofing Technology

When you hear the term sheet metal roofing, think innovation and longevity. Sheet metal starts as flat, thin panels of steel, aluminum, copper, zinc, or stainless steel, shaped through industrial rolling and fabrication. This process allows roofing professionals to cut, bend, and mold the material into customized components that fit any structure.

For commercial buildings, sheet metal is often the go-to choice. Why? Large facilities require roofs that withstand decades of exposure while keeping maintenance costs low. Many commercial roofing and sheet metal projects also help properties qualify for LEED green building certifications, a big win for sustainability-minded companies.

On the residential side, sheet metal roofing has grown in popularity among homeowners. Its sleek look, protective finishes like PVDF coatings, and energy efficiency make it both practical and stylish. And with up to 60% recycled content and complete recyclability, you can feel good about its environmental impact.

Sheet Metal Roofing Materials

Not all sheet metal roofs are the same. Here are the most common sheet metal roofing materials:

• Galvanized steel: affordable and strong, great for most climates.
• Aluminum: lightweight and highly resistant to salt corrosion, perfect for coastal areas.
• Copper: premium, with unmatched durability and a timeless patina.
• Zinc: self-healing and long-lasting, ideal for architectural projects.
• Stainless steel: resilient and corrosion-resistant, often chosen for high-end projects.

Protective coatings like Kynar and Galvalume further improve corrosion resistance and color retention. And with modern fabrication techniques, metal can be shaped into almost any design, ensuring both function and style. Learn more about the benefits of custom sheet metal fabrication for roofing projects.

Types of Sheet Metal Roofing

Sheet metal adapts to different property types and design preferences:

• Standing seam metal roofs: sleek lines, excellent water runoff, ideal for commercial and modern homes.
• Corrugated metal roofing: cost-effective and durable, commonly used for barns and industrial spaces.
• Flat seam roofing: great for custom architectural projects, offering a clean, uniform look.
• Stone-coated metal roofs: blend the classic look of shingles or tile with the strength of metal.

Beyond looks, sheet metal plays a key role in stormwater management. It channels rain efficiently, reducing the chance of pooling or roof damage during storms.

Sheet Metal Roofing Cost

One of the biggest questions is cost. The cost of sheet metal roofing varies by material:

• Steel or aluminum: $8–$12 per sq. ft. installed
• Copper: $15–$25 per sq. ft. installed
• Zinc: $12–$18 per sq. ft. installed

While traditional materials may have a lower upfront cost, sheet metal roofing lasts 40–70 years compared to the 15–30 years of asphalt shingles. Over time, fewer replacements and potential insurance discounts in hail- or fire-prone areas mean significant savings.

Traditional Roofing: Versatile and Affordable Solution

Traditional roofing has been around for centuries, and there’s a reason it’s still widely used. Familiar, affordable, and available in many styles, it’s often the first choice for homeowners who want a classic look. Traditional roofing methods are time-tested, and modern updates have improved their durability.

Traditional Roofing Materials

Here are the most common traditional roofing materials:

• Asphalt shingles: affordable, easy to install, but have a shorter lifespan.
• Clay & concrete tile: heavy but durable, great for hot, dry climates.
• Wood shakes/shingles: rustic appearance, high maintenance, less fire-resistant.
• Traditional slate roofing: elegant and durable, but expensive and heavy.
• Traditional metal roofing: older, simpler tin panels that lack the durability of today’s sheet metal options.

While effective, many of these materials lack the recyclability, energy efficiency, and long lifespan of modern sheet metal.

Traditional Roofing Costs

Average traditional roofing costs (installed):

• Asphalt shingles: $4–$8 per sq. ft. installed
• Tile: $8–$15 per sq. ft. installed
• Wood shakes: $6–$12 per sq. ft. installed
• Slate: $10–$20 per sq. ft. installed

Tile and slate often require extra structural support, which adds hidden costs. And with shorter lifespans, frequent replacements make these options less cost-effective long-term.

Comparison: Sheet Metal vs. Traditional Roofing

Factor	Sheet Metal Roofs	Traditional Roofs	Best For
Upfront Cost	High ($8–$18/sq.ft.)	Low ($4–$8/sq.ft.)	Short-term budgets
Lifespan	40–70+ years	15–50 years	Long-term planning
Climate Suitability	Fire, hail, wind, snow	Hot/dry, historic looks	Harsh climates = metal; warm/dry = tile/slate
Weight	Light (1–3 lbs/sq.ft.)	Heavy (8–12 lbs/sq.ft.)	Older/commercial structures = metal
Energy Efficiency	High (reflective, ENERGY STAR)	Moderate/low	Hot sunny areas = metal
Appearance	Modern & versatile	Classic, bold	Depends on style preference
Maintenance	Low	Moderate–High	Busy owners = metal
Sustainability	Fully recyclable	Limited recycling	Eco-focused = metal

Metal Roofing vs. Traditional Options: How to Decide?

Both metal roofing and traditional options will protect your home or business, but the best choice depends on your unique situation. It’s not a one-size-fits-all decision. Think of it like choosing between a reliable sedan and a rugged SUV; the right fit depends on how, where, and why you use it.

Here’s a simple checklist to help weigh your priorities:

• Budget: Do you need the lowest upfront price, or are you focused on lifecycle savings?
• Climate: Will your roof face hail, snow, wind, or coastal salt air?
• Building weight capacity: Can your structure handle heavy slate or tile, or do you need a lighter material like sheet metal?
• Desired aesthetic: Do you want a sleek, modern look or a more traditional, rustic appearance?
• Maintenance willingness: Are you okay with regular repairs, or do you want a low-maintenance solution?
• Energy efficiency priorities: Do you want reflective, ENERGY STAR-rated panels to cut utility costs?
• Sustainability goals: Do recycled content and recyclability matter to you?

Choosing between these options isn’t always straightforward. Whether you’re leaning toward sheet metal or scheduling traditional roofing services, getting guidance from a trusted contractor is key.

If you’re noticing leaks, worn shingles, or rising energy bills, it might already be time for an upgrade. See the signs you need a roof replacement and get clarity before the damage gets worse.

KRSM: Premier Traditional & Sheet Metal Roofing Experts

With more than 40 years of experience, Kalkreuth Roofing and Sheet Metal has built a reputation as a trusted sheet metal roofing company and residential and commercial contractor in Columbus and across the U.S. From residential roofing services to commercial roofing systems, we handle jobs of every size and complexity.

Our team specializes in custom sheet metal fabrication, innovative designs, and advanced technology that blend function with style. That means you get a roofing system that performs under tough conditions and still delivers on curb appeal. With deep knowledge of the region and a focus on customer satisfaction, we provide solutions that balance durability with budget-conscious planning.

Ready to weigh your options? Contact our experts today for an appointment and get guidance tailored to your property.

Back To News